Short answer: Most AI search advice is untested. We are testing ten common tactics on a brand-new domain, one variable at a time, with verified crawler logs and dated citation checks. Each tactic gets a verdict: supported, not supported or inconclusive. Results so far are below, and the table is updated as tests finish.
How each test works
Every tactic is tested the same way: the claim as it is usually made, the setup that tests it, the result in numbers, and a verdict. “Inconclusive” is a normal outcome.
The scoreboard
| # | Tactic | The claim | How we test it | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | llms.txt | AI crawlers read it and use it to find your best pages | Log every request for llms.txt and check who made it | Running since 29 Oct 2026 |
| 2 | Markdown versions of pages | AI tools prefer clean Markdown to HTML | Log every .md request and every request that asks for Markdown | Running since 29 Oct 2026 |
| 3 | IndexNow | Gets pages into Bing, and so into Copilot, faster | Two articles published at the same moment, one submitted to IndexNow and one not. Compare first crawl and first citation | Running since 5 Nov 2026, 09:00 UTC. First crawl so far: the IndexNow article, 27 seconds after its submission (by YandexBot, which cannot be verified); this article, none yet |
| 4 | JavaScript-rendered content | AI crawlers do not run JavaScript, so they miss it | Two visible test markers on one page: one in the HTML, one added by JavaScript. See which ones engines quote | Planned |
| 5 | FAQ structured data | Helps AI tools lift your answers | Matched articles with and without FAQPage data | Planned |
| 6 | Content Signals | AI crawlers change behavior when you set ai-train or ai-input to no | Four weeks with all signals on, then one switched off, comparing visits by crawler class | Running since 29 Oct 2026 |
| 7 | Google top 10 | You must rank in Google’s top 10 to be cited in AI Overviews | Compare our AI Overview citations with our Search Console positions | Running since 29 Oct 2026 |
| 8 | Backlinks | A page with no backlinks will not be cited | Our first article has no backlinks. Track whether and when it is cited | Running since 29 Oct 2026 |
| 9 | Question headings | Headings phrased as questions get quoted word for word | Check AI answers that cite us for verbatim heading text | Running since 29 Oct 2026 |
| 10 | LinkedIn posts | Sharing on LinkedIn speeds up the first Bing and Copilot crawl | Share one of two matched articles on LinkedIn, then compare first crawl times | Planned |
Last updated: 5 November 2026, 09:25 UTC.
Early observations
On day 0, the first crawler to request our llms.txt file and the Markdown versions of our pages was AhrefsBot, an SEO tool’s crawler, not an AI company’s. Verified crawlers followed later that day: ClaudeBot fetched a Markdown copy at 15:37 UTC and llms.txt at 15:38 UTC, and Google’s GoogleOther crawler fetched both that evening. The full three-day count is in Do AI crawlers read llms.txt? That is not a verdict on tactics 1 or 2; the tests run for at least 30 days.
What we expect
Written before any results: llms.txt and Markdown versions will see little or no verified AI crawler traffic in the first month (tactics 1 and 2). IndexNow will speed up Bing crawling measurably (tactic 3). We have no prediction for tactic 4, because AI crawlers differ on JavaScript and their behavior has changed over time.
What we will not test
Anything that only works by deceiving a search engine or an AI model: showing bots different content from people, hidden text, instructions planted for AI models, fake freshness, bought links. Some of these may “work” for a while. They are not worth the risk to any real site.
Limits
One site, a handful of pages, and engines that change from week to week. A “not supported” verdict here means the tactic made no measurable difference on this site in this window. It does not mean it can never work. Every experiment on this site is listed on our experiments page.
About this article
This article is half of tactic 3. It was published at the same moment as How long does it take a new website to get cited by AI search? and deliberately not submitted to IndexNow; that article was. Its test reference is Census test marker LN-004.
Published by the AI Visibility Census.
Newsletter
Get the next Census by email
Each new edition, list and experiment result, sent when it publishes. About one email a week. One click to leave.